Beer Marketer's Insights
US Sup Ct Rejects Tuff Mass Ad Restrictions
Decision yesterday was big win for tobacco and could make it tuffer for states, local communities to pass (or keep) alc bev billboard bans, other ad restrictions. “Court agreed,” wrote NY Times, that restriction on outside ads (and inside ads that could be seen from outside) “violated the manufacturers’ right to commercial speech.” Tho restrictions aimed at kids, interfered with legit messages to adults. More on decision in Jul Alc Issues INSIGHTS.
Ones we know: Mass; Colo , RI , Vt. In Calif, top dozen import/specialty suppliers shipped nearly 4 mil bbls in 2000, 19 share, so gotta be over 20 there too. Top 3 importers in Calif—Barton, Labatt, Heineken—shipped almost 3 mil bbls alone. Three big specialty players--Sierra, Boston, Redhook—shipped another 370,000 bbls. Import/specialty gotta be over 20 in NY too, tho data not available. Big beer mkts where import/specialty has lotsa room to grow (under 8 share): Tex, Oh, Wisc, Mo.
Cans and Draft Rising
Maris Wraps Up
As Maris trial heads into week 10, looks like AB will start to present its side next week. Maris rested its case midday today. But first, one more witness: Rudy Maris! After not being called by his own atty, judge decided he wants to hear from Rudy, so he’s calling him to testify. Meanwhile, Charlie Walker, sales mgr for Maris’ Ocala location, testified in his 30 yrs he never repackaged old beer or witnessed any other Maris employee do it. Charlie said he got compliments on Maris fleet, that Maris had no turnover problem, that AB district mgr in 93-94 told him Maris “was the best distributor he had.” On cross, AB atty established Rudy was in charge of warehouse and fleet, not Charlie. Charlie never read equity agreement, nor did he understand significance of MET process, and never saw MET results. Roger Maris Jr, general sales mgr, finished his testimony this morning. Details next week.
Another Blow to Bipartisanship
There They Go Again
Cover story in Aug Consumer Reports is beer. First time since 96 that CR has done taste test. Used 2 consultants this time with 20 yrs beer experience. Can’t give results but some folks will be happy, some not and lotsa folks will be surprised. Top-rated domestic lager, not sold by a top 3 brewer or a micro, is getting increasingly hard to find.
Update on Tuff NYC DWI Law
In the 28 mos since New York City started seizing the cars of suspected drunk driving offenders, 4004 vehicles have been taken. That’s avg of 143 per month. No mention in news reports how many people have been able to win car back in court.
AB OK in OH
1st qtr 2001 trends in Ohio, 7th biggest US beer mkt, show AB up 24,000 bbls, 2.4%. Total shipments down 0.6% for 3 mos. Coors continued solid growth: up 7,000 bbls, 6%. (Coors up 7%+ in Oh each of last 4 yrs.) Miller stung: down 34,000 bbls, 7.1%. Big importers rollin’ YTD: Gambrinus jumped 83%, Heineken up 31%, Labatt up 27%. For 12 mos, total shipments eked out 0.3% gain, AB up 0.6%, Miller off 3.6%, Coors up 7%; top-3 importers each up double-digits.
Roger Maris, Jr on Stand
Roger Jr, Maris general sales mgr, testified that he only discovered that former employees had re-packaged old beer during their depositions for this case. Recalled at least 2 employees admitting to it in depositions. AB atty (out of jury’s earshot) told judge that Roger Jr’s statement is a “watershed admission” because “the fact that their employee did it is attributable to Maris Distributing, and it’s that simple.” Also argued law precludes Maris from “arguing that they are not responsible for what their employees did,” whether they knew about it or not.
In earlier testimony, Roger Jr disagreed with AB MET ratings of Maris on everything from warehouse to POS. Said Maris paid salesmen avg salary of $33K per yr, more than competitors paid. Said in summer of 96, former mkt mgr Tom Caddick had “very negative attitude” towards Maris and would try to “spin” and “undermine” employees. In 29 yrs, Roger recalled, Maris Dist fined maybe 4 or 5 employees for “sneaking beer back into the warehouse.” Maris Dist never encouraged employees to repackage old beer, Roger said: “Its just a losing proposition all the way around. . . it’s not our principles and values to do something like that.” More to come from Roger Jr, mother Pat and Uncle Rudy.

